Question Making: Helping Children Turn Curiosity into Enquiry
From Everyday Curiosity to Philosophical Enquiry
Children ask questions constantly. "Why is the sky blue?" "Can I have a snack?" "Who is the fastest runner?" These everyday questions are wonderful starting points, but they are not yet philosophical. Philosophy for Children (P4C) helps pupils transform simple curiosity into deep, open-ended enquiry. The key is to teach children how to move from factual or personal questions to questions that explore concepts, reasons, and values.

In this article, we share two practical techniques — question stems and sorting activities — that support this shift. Both are simple to use in any classroom and work well with pupils from age five upwards.
What Makes a Question Philosophical?
A philosophical question is contestable, meaning it has no single correct answer. It invites reasoning, listening, and building on others' ideas. For example, "How many legs does a spider have?" is a factual question. "Is it fair to keep a spider in a jar?" is philosophical because it asks about fairness, freedom, and care.
Children often begin with questions that can be answered by a quick search or a teacher's knowledge. Our goal is not to dismiss those questions but to help pupils see the difference and then stretch their thinking. A useful rule of thumb: if everyone agrees immediately, it is probably not philosophical. If people can disagree with good reasons, it is.
Technique 1: Question Stems to Lift Thinking
Question stems are sentence starters that guide pupils towards more abstract thinking. Instead of asking "What is a friend?", a stem might be "Is it possible to be friends with someone you have never met?" The stem does the heavy lifting, giving pupils a structure to explore.
Here are some effective philosophical question stems you can display or hand out:
- Is it ever right to...?
- What makes something...?
- Can we know if...?
- Should we always...?
- What is the difference between... and...?
Ask pupils to take an everyday question and rewrite it using a stem. For instance, "Why do we have rules?" becomes "Should we always follow rules, even when they seem unfair?" This small shift turns a simple question into a rich enquiry.
Technique 2: Sorting Activities to Identify Philosophical Questions
Sorting activities give pupils a hands-on way to recognise the difference between question types. Provide a set of mixed questions on cards or a worksheet. In pairs or small groups, pupils sort them into three categories: closed (factual), open (personal or speculative), and philosophical (contestable and conceptual).
After sorting, ask groups to explain their reasoning. This discussion is itself philosophical. You can use a simple table like this to organise the questions:
| Question | Type | Why? |
|---|---|---|
| How many planets are there? | Closed | One correct answer, verifiable. |
| Would you like to live on Mars? | Open (personal) | Depends on personal preference. |
| Is it fair to colonise another planet? | Philosophical | Explores fairness, rights, and consequences. |
Once pupils are confident, challenge them to turn a closed or open question into a philosophical one. This metacognitive step is where real learning happens.
Building a Culture of Enquiry
These techniques work best when the classroom is a safe space for wondering. Encourage pupils to build on each other's ideas, to ask "Why do you think that?" and to change their minds when they hear a better reason.
Remember the words of philosopher Matthew Lipman: "The aim of philosophy is not to answer questions but to question answers." By using question stems and sorting activities, we help children turn their natural curiosity into a lifelong habit of thoughtful enquiry.

"A philosophical question is one that invites us to think together, not to find a single answer."